Custom Orders

Make your celebration even sweeter with our custom cookie favor boxes. Each box is filled with your choice of our handcrafted, naturally colored sugar cookies, and tied with a ribbon in the color of your choice.

Inside each favor box:

  • Two mini Cookie Friend sugar cookies: Choose up to two different Cookie Friends to match your party theme.

  • Cookie Charms: Choose up to three different cookie charm shapes to fill the box.

We feature our three signature Cookie Friends to choose from - Penny Panda, Cheddar Cat, and Frankie Pup. If you have another animal in mind, we would be happy to explore new custom animal designs with you! 

Favors start at $8 per box. Minimum order is 12 boxes.

Available for local pickup in West Hartford, CT. Delivery may be available for an additional fee.

To get started, click the button below to let us know about the fun you’re planning!

Cookie Party Favors

Request Party Favors

Our cookie gift tins make a beautiful and unique handcrafted gift for any occasion. Each tin is filled with an assortment of cookies colored with plant-based ingredients and finished with our signature custom wax seal.

Inside each tin:

  • Mini Cookie Friend sugar cookies

  • Cookie Charm sugar cookies

  • Classic shortbread cookies

  • Strawberry shortbread cookies

  • Classic butter cookie flowers

  • Pandan butter cookie swirls

Cookie tins are $30 each, currently available in one size (3⅝” x 5” x 1⅝”). Minimum order is 2 tins.

Cookie Gift Tins - Available Soon!

Request Cookie Tins